Monday, 28 March 2016

More decentralization, please!

by Kabeer Dawani and Ammar Khalid

From left to right: Mr Arif Hasan, Nalini Shekar, Dr Noman Ahmed, Ammar Khalid, Kabeer Dawani and Dr Asad Sayeed
Photo credits: LUMS HSS

In 2015, for the first time Pakistan held local government elections across all four provinces under a civilian government. All three tiers of government are now democratically elected – something that is unprecedented in Pakistan’s history. However, while this is a crucial step in the right direction, the laws enacted by the four provinces are restrictive and have been criticized by various quarters for not devolving any meaningful powers to the local bodies.

At the recent 10th Annual HSS Conference, held at the Lahore University of Management Sciences, we presented a paper that looked at the relationship between decentralization and urban service delivery. Specifically, we examined municipal service delivery in a multi-ethnic locality in Karachi.

One of the benefits of decentralization widely cited in the literature is the increase in accountability and subsequent improvement in service delivery. Our research, which looked into decentralization between 2001 and 2010, found that lower tiers of government were more efficient as compared to higher tiers of government in terms of municipal service delivery. However, crucially, the ability to deliver these services largely depends on the union council or town government having the resources – financial and otherwise – to do so. In the absence of fiscal decentralization – both, transferring funds to local governments and empowering them to raise their own funds – local bodies will remain powerless to solve issues of service delivery.

Moreover, fiscal empowerment of local governments is not only important for better public good provision, it is also vital for more equitable service delivery. In an ethnically heterogeneous setting like Karachi, we found that service provision was pivoted upon the dynamics of political competition in the area. Thus, when the party in power at the city level was not the one in power at the union council level, delivery was worse than when the same party was in power. This is because the union council was deprived of funds by the city government, which chose to direct resources towards, and in turn patronize, their own constituencies first – evidence of the weak institutional structure.

In the current local government set up, minimal fiscal decentralization has taken place. In fact, only about 5% of Pakistan’s public spending is undertaken at the local level, in stark contrast to India, where it is about 30%.

The reason for the lack of empowerment of local governments has to do with the fact that historically devolution has been used (by military regimes) to bypass political parties, which are best organized at the provincial level. Political parties are therefore skeptical of devolving power further below the provinces. The recent elections were only held, after many delays, due to pressure from the Supreme Court of Pakistan.

It will take time for the parties to come to terms with devolving meaningful power to the local level. It is now the opposition parties in all four provinces which must mobilize and campaign for greater decentralization of powers. In the long run, this will result in institutional strengthening, which will improve public service delivery.


  1. Am Lucy Morgan from Atlanta Georgia i was suffering from genital herpes, oral herpes, shingles. Before I came in contact with dr. Kham It is no longer news that the Acquired immune deficiency syndrome Herpes Virus is increasing by the day, The fear is that many people living with the sickness are scared of saying it because of the stigma that comes along with it.I am bold enough among many others to state that there is now a potent cure to this sickness but many are unaware of it.I discovered that I was infected with the virus 3 months ago, after a medical check-up. My doctor told me and I was shocked, confused and felt like my world had crumbled. I was dying slowly due to the announcement of my medical practitioner but he assured me that I could live a normal life if I took my medications, In a bid to look for a lasting solution to my predicament, I sought for solutions from the voodoo world. I went online and searched for every powerful trado-medical practitioner that I could severe, because I heard that the African Voodoo Priests had a cure for Herpes syndrome. It was after a little time searching the web that I came across one Dr. Kham website who offered to help me, He gave me some steps to follow and I meticulously carried out all his instructions. Two days ago to be precise, I went back to the hospital to conduct another test and to my amazement, the results showed that " I am NEGATIVE" You can free yourself of this Herpes virus by consulting this great African Voodoo Priest via this EMAIL or] WHATSAPP NUMBER +2348159922297, You can Also Visit his website to know more about him at >


    PREGNANCY spell

    EPILEPSY cure spell












    HEPATITIS A B and C.


  2. I still don’t know the right words to express my gratitude to this great man Dr. Uromi. After been diagnosed of HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS in 2months ago, i was given so many health prescription and advice with no improvement, I totally lost hope, until i found testimonies of Great Dr. Uromi online research and on Facebook, Like anybody would be, I was very skeptical about contacting him, but i later did and he opened up to me and told me what was involved and he started the remedies for my health. Thank God, I was cured from herpes by the herbal medication I received from him. I never thought that herpes can be cured, from the bottom of my heart I'm truly grateful,i pray you have long life so you can help many more people on earth with your herbal medical support, You can Email him via email or for easy and fast communication you can also call or add him on whats-app with this mobile number +2349021374574 , one thing i love most about DR Uromi is honestly, and he is very polite with his patience, everything he told me was what he did, and his herbal medicine are very affordable