Friday, 4 December 2015

Politics and social change

by Haris Gazdar

Pakistan's youngest political prisoner: 4 year old MRD activist Fraz Wahlah, 1985
Photo credit: Wikipedia

Last Saturday, I spoke at a panel discussion - “Pakistan: fossilized or quietly transforming” at the 2015 Khayaal Festival. Dr. Ali Cheema who teaches economics at the LUMS and conducts research at the Institute of Development and Economic Alternatives (IDEAS) and the Centre for Economic Research in Pakistan (CERP) moderated the discussion. I was privileged to share the panel with the distinguished demographer and social scientist Dr Zeba Sathar who heads the Pakistan country office of the Population Council in Pakistan and does pathbreaking work on fertility and demographic trends.

Has Pakistan changed, or is it caught in a rut? Ali Cheema introduced this question using the work of two commentators on Pakistan, William Easterly and Anatol Lieven. Easterly wonders why Pakistan lags behind in so many social indicators of education, health, and women’s empowerment despite having a relatively educated and sophisticated elite, and having produced many individuals who excel in the professions globally. Lieven characterizes Pakistan as being “governed by the traditions of overriding loyalty to family, clan and religion... a highly conservative, archaic... inert mass of different societies".

Zeba Sathar set the tone for the discussion by pointing out that statistically speaking, Pakistan was changing, and perhaps changing rather more rapidly than often appreciated. She went to the core institution that supposedly holds Pakistani society or societies together, or holds them back – the family. She pointed to evidence that men and women in Pakistan desire a different family than what has been traditionally inherited or imagined. The decline in fertility is indicative of this forward-looking disposition of the people, and the conservatism, if any, is that of the state. People are desperate for greater agency to plan their families, have fewer children, and think actively about the lives of future generations. Such is the desperation that in the absence of an active policy with respect to family planning and reproductive health, couples are deciding for women to have induced abortions in ever-increasing numbers.

I talked about how the failure of the state and conservative educational outcomes are connected across countries. The literacy transition – or the transformation of a society in which only the elites could read or write, to one where literacy was the norm – has almost without exception been a societal project driven by the state. Sweden was the first major country to achieve universal literacy in the modern era. The Lutheran Protestant Church, motivated by a missionary zeal to spread the reading of the Bible in the Swedish language, led this movement up to the 18th century. In the 19th century, a more secular mission was overtaken by the Swedish state to produce citizens through the public schooling system. Both the early religious effort and the subsequent secular one first imagined a uniform society and then created it through administrative methods. Countries with diverse political complexions (for example much of Europe, Turkey, and China), which followed suit had similar societal impulses forged into elite agreements and popular participation.

Pakistan, unlike Sweden and other countries that have undergone a literacy transition, lacks an active state that acts as an instrument for social change. This is perhaps because there is an absence of consensus among elites about the direction of social change. A deficit in agreeing upon the contours of an imagined community was revealed early on. The first national education conference held in November 1947 shied away from a political debate on whether and to what extent the state will espouse religious or ethnic identities of its constituents. It is only recently that the political process has begun to come to terms with these disparate elements of Pakistani identity. The lack of state action, in a country of segmented communities and societies, has led to fragmented outcomes. In our work, we find that ALL children belonging to a particular caste or kinship group in a village may have finished secondary schooling, and hardly any from another kinship group is even enrolled in the primary level.

The paradoxes which Easterly and Lieven point to might be all too real, but to see them simply as signs of social conservatism and elite indifference is almost tautological. Social change is primarily a political question.


  1. Am Lucy Morgan from Atlanta Georgia i was suffering from genital herpes, oral herpes, shingles. Before I came in contact with dr. Kham It is no longer news that the Acquired immune deficiency syndrome Herpes Virus is increasing by the day, The fear is that many people living with the sickness are scared of saying it because of the stigma that comes along with it.I am bold enough among many others to state that there is now a potent cure to this sickness but many are unaware of it.I discovered that I was infected with the virus 3 months ago, after a medical check-up. My doctor told me and I was shocked, confused and felt like my world had crumbled. I was dying slowly due to the announcement of my medical practitioner but he assured me that I could live a normal life if I took my medications, In a bid to look for a lasting solution to my predicament, I sought for solutions from the voodoo world. I went online and searched for every powerful trado-medical practitioner that I could severe, because I heard that the African Voodoo Priests had a cure for Herpes syndrome. It was after a little time searching the web that I came across one Dr. Kham website who offered to help me, He gave me some steps to follow and I meticulously carried out all his instructions. Two days ago to be precise, I went back to the hospital to conduct another test and to my amazement, the results showed that " I am NEGATIVE" You can free yourself of this Herpes virus by consulting this great African Voodoo Priest via this EMAIL or] WHATSAPP NUMBER +2348159922297, You can Also Visit his website to know more about him at >


    PREGNANCY spell

    EPILEPSY cure spell












    HEPATITIS A B and C.


  2. I Want To Appreciate Dr.OYAGU for his great deeds, I Was Diagnosed With type 2 Herpes Virus Last year,And i Was Looking For Solution To Be Cured Luckily I Saw Testimonies On How Dr.OYAGU Cure Herpes Virus I Decided To Contact Dr.OYAGU I Contacted Him He Prepared A Herbal Medicine Portion And Sent It To Me,I Started The Herbal Medicine For My Health.He Gave Me Step By Step Instructions On How To Apply It, When I Applied It As Instructed, I Was Cured Of This Deadly Herpes Within 2 weeks, I Am Now Herpes Negative.My Brother And Sister I No That There Are So Many People That Have The Same Herpes Virus Please contact Dr OYAGU To Help You Too,And Help Me To Thank Dr.OYAGU For Cure Me, I’m Cured By Dr. OYAGU Herbal Medicine,His Contact
    Or Cell Whatsapp Number +2348101755322 thank you

  3. I have had (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) disease over the past six years and I've been in constant pain, especially on my knees. During the first year, I believed in God that one day I would be cured. This disease began spreading all over my body, and I was receiving treatment from my doctor, a few months ago, I searched on the internet if I could get any information about the treatment of this disease, and in my research, I saw a testimony from someone who had recovered from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) By this man, Dr. Uromi she gave this man the email address, and we recommend contacting him in case of illness that will help him, so I wrote to Dr Uromi the to tell him about my (HERPES virus) well after all the procedures and treatments that this man gave me a few weeks later I started experiencing changes everywhere. Now I'm here to testify that I am no longer sick with herpes, I have experience a total transformation in my life, because all herpes patients get your herbal medicine to treat your disease. There is a rapid improvement in my health, I no longer feel pain and wake up every morning feeling energetic. So my friends advise if you have such a disease or any other disease at all, you can contact him on any of these diseases WhatsApp +2349021374574 Email: